What plans cut when they lose the quality bonus

Benefits and rebates in Medicare Advantage contracts that lost the Star Ratings bonus.

Architectural elevation of a farmhouse with one side wing drawn in dashed lines, marked for removal

The short answer

Medicare Advantage contracts that lost the Star Ratings quality bonus cut supplemental benefits more often than contracts that kept it. 5.4% of 258 lost-bonus contracts cut comprehensive dental, against 2.1% of 852 that kept the bonus, and their rebates moved about $6-7 PMPM less in the two transitions with rebate data. These are signals from 3PS analysis of CMS data, not proof of cause and effect.

5.4% vs 2.1%

Cut comprehensive dental

258 lost-bonus vs 852 kept-bonus contracts

18.8% vs 10.0%

Cut home safety devices

80 lost-bonus vs 269 kept-bonus contracts

9.2% vs 5.6%

Cut OTC benefits

261 lost-bonus vs 841 kept-bonus contracts

$6-7 PMPM

Smaller rebate change

lost-bonus vs kept-bonus, two transitions

Source: 3PS analysis of CMS plan benefit and payment data, five bonus transitions pooled, build 27 Oct 2026.

Which benefits get cut after a bonus loss

Across five pooled bonus transitions, contracts that lost the bonus cut comprehensive dental, home safety devices and over-the-counter (OTC) benefits more often than contracts that kept it. The gap is widest for home safety devices: 18.8% against 10.0%.

Cut comprehensive dental, share of contracts

Lost the bonus

258 contracts

5.4%

Kept the bonus

852 contracts

2.1%

Cut home safety devices, share of contracts

Lost the bonus

80 contracts

18.8%

Kept the bonus

269 contracts

10.0%

Cut OTC benefits, share of contracts

Lost the bonus

261 contracts

9.2%

Kept the bonus

841 contracts

5.6%

Never had the bonus

9.0%

Source: 3PS analysis of CMS plan benefit and payment data, five bonus transitions pooled, build 27 Oct 2026.

OTC cuts look like plans that never had the bonus

Contracts that lost the bonus cut OTC benefits at 9.2%, close to the 9.0% of contracts that never had the bonus. Contracts that kept it cut OTC at 5.6%.

The same pattern shows in 2027 bids. At bid-time ratings, 16.6% of members in lost-bonus plans saw an OTC cut, against 11.8% of members in plans that kept the bonus.

Members in plans with a 2027 OTC cut, at bid-time ratings

Lost the bonus

16.6%

Kept the bonus

11.8%

Source: 3PS analysis of CMS plan benefit and payment data, five bonus transitions pooled, build 27 Oct 2026.

How rebates move after a bonus loss

In the two transitions with rebate data, lost-bonus contracts' rebates moved about $6-7 PMPM less than those of contracts that kept the bonus. That held whether rebates rose or fell overall.

+$18.0

Lost the bonus, 2021-22

rebate change, PMPM

+$25.2

Kept the bonus, 2021-22

rebate change, PMPM

-$10.2

Lost the bonus, 2023-24

rebate change, PMPM

-$3.9

Kept the bonus, 2023-24

rebate change, PMPM

How to read these signals

These figures show what tends to move after a bonus loss. They do not show that the bonus loss caused it.

Not cause and effect

Contracts that lose the bonus may differ from those that keep it in other ways, and those differences can drive benefit choices too.

The same contracts recur

Pooling five transitions means some contracts appear in more than one year, so these are signals, not proof.

Offered or not, not dollar amounts

The benefit data shows whether a contract offers a benefit, not how much the benefit is worth.

Rebate data covers two transitions

Rebate changes are shown only for the 2021-22 and 2023-24 transitions, the two with rebate data.

Questions and answers

What happens when a Medicare Advantage plan loses its Star Ratings bonus?

Contracts that lost the quality bonus cut supplemental benefits more often than contracts that kept it, according to 3PS analysis of CMS plan benefit and payment data across five pooled bonus transitions. 5.4% of 258 lost-bonus contracts cut comprehensive dental, against 2.1% of 852 that kept the bonus.

Which supplemental benefits are cut most often after a bonus loss?

Home safety devices show the widest gap: 18.8% of 80 lost-bonus contracts cut them, against 10.0% of 269 that kept the bonus. OTC benefits were cut by 9.2% of 261 lost-bonus contracts, against 5.6% of 841 that kept it.

How do Medicare Advantage rebates change after a plan loses the bonus?

In the two transitions with rebate data, lost-bonus contracts' rebates moved about $6-7 PMPM less than kept-bonus contracts'. In 2021-22, rebates rose $18.0 PMPM for lost-bonus contracts and $25.2 for kept. In 2023-24, they fell $10.2 for lost and $3.9 for kept.

Did plans that lost the bonus cut OTC benefits for 2027?

At bid-time ratings, 16.6% of members in lost-bonus plans saw a 2027 OTC cut, against 11.8% of members in plans that kept the bonus.

Does losing the bonus cause these benefit cuts?

The data does not show cause and effect. The same contracts recur across years, so the patterns are signals, not proof, and the data shows whether a benefit is offered, not its dollar amount.

How is the quality bonus payment tied to Star Ratings?

Medicare Advantage contracts rated 4 stars or higher earn a quality bonus payment, and contracts below 4 stars do not. The 2028 Star Ratings watch list shows which contracts sit closest to that line.

Plan for the benefit changes ahead

If you sell into plans near the 4-star line, we'll show you which benefits and markets the data points to.

Value proven. Value delivered. Outcomes realized.