2028 Medicare Star Ratings watch list

Which Medicare Advantage contracts sit closest to the 4-star bonus line.

Pencil drawing of a celestial star chart crossed by a dashed line, with one small cluster of stars just below it

The short answer

In CMS's Stars 2027 ratings, 166 Medicare Advantage contracts are rated 3.5 stars, covering 6,847,706 members, and get no 2028 quality bonus. Another 109 contracts sit at exactly 4.0 stars, and 29 of them, with 4,013,866 members, would drop to 3.5 if one measure lost one star. This is a risk ranking from 3PS analysis of CMS data, not a forecast.

166

Contracts at 3.5 stars

6,847,706 members, no 2028 bonus

109

Contracts at exactly 4.0

12,456,557 members

29

4.0 contracts one measure star from 3.5

4,013,866 members

23

Can drop on blood pressure or blood sugar control alone

2,578,837 members

Source: 3PS analysis of CMS Stars 2027 ratings released 8 Oct 2026. Members are whole-contract enrollment, October 2026.

Which contracts miss the bonus at 3.5 stars

166 Medicare Advantage contracts are rated 3.5 stars in Stars 2027, covering 6,847,706 members. A 3.5-star rating earns no 2028 quality bonus payment.

60 of the 166 just fell from 4.0 stars or higher, and they hold 4,443,839 members. For those contracts, the bonus was there one rating cycle ago.

Members in contracts rated 3.5 stars, Stars 2027

All 166 contracts at 3.5

6,847,706

60 that just fell from 4.0 or higher

4,443,839

31 one measure star away from 4.0

1,462,894

115 that need 0.25 points or more

4,167,725

Source: 3PS analysis of CMS Stars 2027 ratings released 8 Oct 2026. Members are whole-contract enrollment, October 2026.

31 are close to 4.0

31 of the 166 contracts, with 1,462,894 members, are one measure star away from 4.0.

115 need more than one measure

115 contracts, with 4,167,725 members, need 0.25 points or more to reach 4.0.

Which 4-star contracts could slip to 3.5

109 contracts sit at exactly 4.0 stars, covering 12,456,557 members. 29 of them, with 4,013,866 members, drop to 3.5 if one measure loses one star.

3PS ranks the 29 by risk: 22 high-risk contracts hold 2,585,996 members and 7 medium-risk contracts hold 1,427,870.

Members in contracts rated exactly 4.0, Stars 2027

All 109 contracts at 4.0

12,456,557

29 at risk of dropping to 3.5

4,013,866

22 high risk

2,585,996

7 medium risk

1,427,870

Source: 3PS analysis of CMS Stars 2027 ratings released 8 Oct 2026. Members are whole-contract enrollment, October 2026.

The measures that carry the most risk

Blood pressure control or blood sugar control alone can drop 23 contracts, with 2,578,837 members.

CAHPS member survey measures are not in this count: they have no gap figure, so the watch list cannot say how close a contract is on them.

23

Contracts

can drop on blood pressure or blood sugar control alone

2,578,837

Members

in those 23 contracts

How to read this watch list

The watch list ranks how close each contract sits to a rating line. It does not predict a 2028 rating.

A risk ranking, not a forecast

It shows which contracts are nearest the line on Stars 2027 results, not which ones will move.

2028 cut points are not known

CMS has not set the 2028 cut points, and they will move the line for every contract.

Survey measures have no gap figure

CAHPS survey measures are left out of the one-measure counts because no gap can be measured for them.

Stars 2027 can still change

CMS is appealing the Clover ruling, so the Stars 2027 ratings behind this list can still change. See the analysis of the ruling.

Questions and answers

How many Medicare Advantage contracts are rated 3.5 stars in Stars 2027?

166 contracts, covering 6,847,706 members, according to 3PS analysis of CMS Stars 2027 ratings released 8 Oct 2026. A 3.5-star rating earns no 2028 quality bonus. 60 of the 166 just fell from 4.0 or higher, with 4,443,839 members.

Which 4-star contracts are closest to dropping to 3.5?

109 contracts sit at exactly 4.0 stars, covering 12,456,557 members. 29 of them, with 4,013,866 members, drop to 3.5 if one measure loses one star: 22 high risk (2,585,996 members) and 7 medium risk (1,427,870 members).

Which Star Ratings measures carry the most risk for 4-star contracts?

Blood pressure control or blood sugar control alone can drop 23 contracts, with 2,578,837 members, according to 3PS analysis of CMS data. CAHPS survey measures have no gap figure, so they are not in that count.

Are the 2028 Star Ratings cut points known?

No. CMS has not set the 2028 cut points, so this watch list is a risk ranking based on Stars 2027 results, not a forecast of 2028 ratings.

Can the Stars 2027 ratings still change?

Yes. CMS is appealing the Clover ruling, so the Stars 2027 ratings, and any watch list built on them, can still change.

What does a 3.5-star rating mean for a Medicare Advantage plan?

A contract rated below 4 stars does not earn the quality bonus payment. In Stars 2027, 166 contracts with 6,847,706 members are rated 3.5 and get no 2028 bonus. Reaching 4.0 in a later rating can restore a future bonus.

See where your contracts sit

Tell us which contracts or markets you watch, and we'll walk you through the Star Ratings risk in the data.

Value proven. Value delivered. Outcomes realized.